by NicoPublished on Updated on 3 min read

On the ramparts, the bird eyeing your chips is almost never the small gull people picture when they say “seagull”. It is a herring gull, and four species share this coast. Only one of them is a small gull.
Telling them apart in three seconds
| Species | Length | Wingspan | Bill | Legs | Back |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Black-headed gull | 38 to 44 cm | about 1 m | slim, dark red | dark red | pale grey, chocolate hood in summer |
| Herring gull | 55 to 67 cm | 1.30 to 1.58 m | heavy, yellow, red spot below | pink | pale grey |
| Lesser black-backed gull | 52 to 67 cm | 1.35 to 1.50 m | yellow, red spot | yellow | slate grey to near black |
| Great black-backed gull | 61 to 78 cm | 1.50 to 1.70 m | very heavy, yellow | pink | black |
The weights say it all: a black-headed gull weighs 225 to 350 grams, a herring gull 750 to 1,250 grams. Three to four times more. A great black-backed gull can reach two kilos.
The giveaway is the legs
Size is hard to judge when the bird is alone on a roof, and the shade of the back changes with the light. The legs never lie.
- Dark red: black-headed gull
- Pink: herring gull, or great black-backed gull if the back is black
- Yellow: lesser black-backed gull
Second clue, the bill: slim and red on the small gull, massive and yellow with a red spot under the tip on every adult large gull.
The one that steals your chips
The herring gull, sometimes the lesser black-backed. With a 1.50 m wingspan and a kilo of muscle, it has the power to drop onto a hand and leave with the contents. The black-headed gull, three times lighter, settles for crumbs on the ground and for the sandbanks at low tide.
The call gives the species away too. That loud repeated laugh heard over the walled city at five in the morning is the herring gull. The black-headed gull, despite being called “mouette rieuse”, the laughing gull, in French, only makes a short harsh screech.
Young birds are the real trap
A herring gull takes about four years to reach adult plumage. Until then it is mottled brown, its bill stays dark, and it matches none of the descriptions above. Many of the “strange big brown birds” photographed on the Sillon beach are simply second or third year herring gulls.
In that case go by size and shape. A juvenile already has its parents’ build.
Protected birds, managed by egg sterilisation
Gulls are protected species in France. They cannot be killed and their nests cannot be destroyed without a special exemption. Saint-Malo is one of the towns in Ille-et-Vilaine covered by a request for an exemption allowing egg sterilisation, alongside Rennes and Dinard. The egg is shaken or coated so the embryo stops developing, the pair keeps incubating and does not lay a second clutch.
Feeding a gull is still a bad idea. A bird used to human food becomes bold, and it is that boldness that ends up causing trouble for everyone, the bird included.
Two good places to watch them: the walk around the ramparts, where the large gulls nest on the roofs below, and the beaches at low tide, where the small gulls work the foreshore.
Frequently asked questions about the gulls of Saint-Malo
What is the difference in one sentence?
The black-headed gull is small, with a dark red bill and dark red legs. The large gulls are big, with a yellow bill carrying a red spot and legs that are pink or yellow.
Which one is on the roofs of the walled city?
Herring gulls, and some lesser black-backed gulls. The small black-headed gulls stay on the foreshore and in the harbours.
Why does the black-headed gull have a brown hood?
It is the breeding plumage, from March to July. In winter only a dark smudge behind the eye remains, and many people no longer recognise the same bird.
Can a gull attack a person?
It can dive at you to defend a nest or a chick, mainly in June and July. It is intimidation rather than attack: move away from that roof or that stretch of beach and it stops.
How do I recognise a great black-backed gull?
By the solidly black back and the size: up to 78 cm and a 1.70 m wingspan, with pink legs. It is the largest gull in the world.
